KSTP · 5 Eyewitness News
The Renee Good shooting: what two camera angles showed
Minnesota criminal defense attorney
In two interviews a day apart, Rob Doar discussed how the agent’s position, the moving SUV and newly released cellphone footage affected his reading of the later shots.
On January 8, KSTP’s Ryan Raiche asked Doar to review footage of the shooting of Renee Good in Minneapolis. The later shots drew his attention to the agent’s changing position relative to Good’s SUV. A view from beside the vehicle raised a question about whether the agent still faced the same danger when he fired again.
The next day, WCCO’s Jeff Wagner asked him to assess video recorded by the agent. Doar explained what he reconsidered. The speed of the encounter could have left the agent little time to register a change in danger. Good’s demeanor and the agent’s decision to move in front of the vehicle also mattered. Read together, the interviews show why identifying the vantage point is essential to any account of what the agent could perceive.
For the constitutional question, the Supreme Court requires courts to consider the whole encounter in deciding whether force was reasonable. Barnes v. Felix, 605 U.S. 73, 79–81 (2025). The reports document what was visible when they aired.