
Boelter venue ruling · November 13, 2026 · Reported November 17, 2026
Hennepin County plans to summon 500 prospective jurors for Vance Boelter’s state trial. One question I’d want answered is what each of them thinks Boelter’s federal guilty plea has already decided. Someone who remembers the plea may be perfectly capable of serving. Someone who expects the defense to explain why there’s any need for a state trial has given the lawyers a reason to keep asking questions. Reporting on jury selection.
Boelter pleaded guilty in federal court in June to charges arising from the killings of former Minnesota House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, and the attack on Sen. John Hoffman and his family. The state charges remain pending. On November 13, Judge Juan Hoyos denied the defense request to move the trial outside the Twin Cities. According to reporting on the order, Hoyos found little support for the assumption that prospective jurors elsewhere in Minnesota had encountered substantially less coverage. The court plans to send a 54-question questionnaire to the expanded pool before trial. Federal plea · State charges · Venue ruling coverage.
What Minnesota Requires Before Trial
Minnesota ordinarily tries a criminal case in the county where the alleged offense occurred. The state constitution also guarantees the accused an impartial jury. When publicity puts those interests in tension, Rule 25.02 directs the judge to grant a continuance or change of venue if potentially prejudicial material creates a reasonable likelihood that the defendant cannot receive a fair trial. The next sentence is unusually plain. “Actual prejudice need not be shown.” Minn. Const. art. I, § 6. Minn. R. Crim. P. 24.01, 24.03, subd. 1(d), 25.02, subd. 3.
What would make that showing? A survey finding that most residents recognize Boelter’s name would establish something few people dispute. A survey asking whether residents believe the federal plea settles the state charges would tell the judge considerably more. Comparing those answers across counties could also show whether moving the trial would help. Minnesota allows qualified surveys, community testimony and other evidence with probative value. The rule prescribes no particular poll and requires no collection of affidavits from local residents. Minn. R. Crim. P. 25.02, subd. 2.
Minnesota has moved a murder trial across a county line even when the two counties shared much of the same news. In State v. Thompson, newspapers carried police officials’ assessments of a St. Paul murder case, including the police chief’s conclusion about the motive. The Minnesota Supreme Court read the articles and ordered the trial moved from Ramsey County to Hennepin County. The prosecution had a fair point that people in Minneapolis could read the same stories. What persuaded the court was the substance of what officials had said and the atmosphere those statements had created in Ramsey County. State v. Thompson, 123 N.W.2d 378, 381–82 (Minn. 1963).
Chauvin’s Request Was Denied Twice
Judge Peter Cahill first denied Derek Chauvin’s venue motion on November 4, 2020, four months before jury selection. The order was expressly preliminary. Cahill invited more evidence and explained why he wanted questionnaires from the people actually summoned to serve. Their answers, he reasoned, could tell him more than a poll of Hennepin County residents generally. Preliminary Order Regarding Change of Venue at 1, 8, State v. Chauvin, No. 27-CR-20-12646 (Minn. Dist. Ct. Nov. 4, 2020).
Then something happened that no November questionnaire could have anticipated. On March 12, 2021, with jury selection underway, Minneapolis announced a $27 million civil settlement with George Floyd’s family. Chauvin renewed his request on March 15. Cahill recalled the seven jurors already seated. After hearing their answers, he excused two for cause because of the effect the settlement news had on them. On March 19, he denied the renewed requests to move or delay the trial. Court of Appeals opinion, slip op. at 8–9 · March 19 ruling.
Those two dismissals were evidence that the defense had identified a real problem. They also gave the judge a basis to explain why the trial could proceed. He had questioned the jurors individually, allowed the lawyers to do the same, and removed people whose answers showed the settlement had affected their judgment. On appeal after conviction, the court reviewed that record for abuse of discretion. It found no showing that the jurors who decided the case were actually biased and no basis to presume prejudice. State v. Chauvin, 989 N.W.2d 1, 19–22 (Minn. Ct. App. 2023).
The Question Boelter’s Jury Must Answer
One detail in the Chauvin opinion deserves attention here. In declining to presume prejudice, the Court of Appeals specifically observed that the publicity had included no confession by Chauvin to the charged crimes. Boelter’s federal guilty plea is public. Whatever evidence the state judge ultimately admits, Hennepin County prosecutors still have to prove each state charge beyond a reasonable doubt. A prospective juror who has already crossed that bridge deserves more than a yes-or-no question about being fair. Chauvin, 989 N.W.2d at 21–22. Minn. Stat. § 611.02.
I’d start with an open question: What do you understand Boelter admitted in federal court, and what do you believe the State of Minnesota still has to prove? The answer gives both lawyers something they can examine. If enough prospective jurors can keep the two proceedings straight, their answers support keeping the trial in Hennepin County. If answer after answer reveals that people regard a state verdict as a formality, the defense has better evidence for a renewed motion than it had in November. Minnesota expressly allows a judge to reconsider a venue denial, even after the jury is sworn. Five hundred summonses give the court room to find a fair jury. The answers will tell the judge whether it has. Minn. R. Crim. P. 25.02, subd. 4.
Sources & Further Reading
- WCCO, Judge Denies Vance Boelter’s Change of Venue Request for State Trial (Nov. 17, 2026).
- U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Minnesota, Boelter Pleaded Guilty for His Role in the Stalking and Murder of Minnesota State Legislators (June 11, 2026).
- Hennepin County Attorney’s Office, State Charges Against Vance Boelter Following His Federal Guilty Plea.
- KTTC, Judge Denies Request to Move Vance Boelter Trial Out of Hennepin County (Nov. 17, 2026).
- Minn. Const. art. I, § 6.
- Minn. R. Crim. P. 24.01, 24.03, subd. 1(d).
- Minn. R. Crim. P. 25.02, subds. 2–4.
- State v. Thompson, 123 N.W.2d 378, 381–82 (Minn. 1963).
- Preliminary Order Regarding Change of Venue at 1, 8, State v. Chauvin, No. 27-CR-20-12646 (Minn. Dist. Ct. Nov. 4, 2020).
- State v. Chauvin, 989 N.W.2d 1, 19–22 (Minn. Ct. App. 2023). See also slip op. at 8–9 (jury selection).
- FOX 9, Judge Denies Motion to Delay or Move Derek Chauvin Trial (Mar. 19, 2021).
- Minn. Stat. § 611.02.
Questions About a Minnesota Criminal Case?
Rob and his team can discuss the charges, jury selection, and what to expect at trial.
Schedule a Free Consultation