Legal Notes · Gun rights

DOJ Reopened Federal Gun Rights Restoration. Minnesota Law Already Says What a Grant Does.

Minnesota’s lifetime firearm prohibition has a federal exception written into it. For more than thirty years, the problem was getting the federal government to decide whether you qualified.

By Rob DoarArticle Date:
Minnesota State Capitol framed by bare branches above an autumn lawn.
Editorial illustration of the Minnesota State Capitol.

Read the first sentence of Minn. Stat. § 609.165, subd. 1a, and you’ll find the words most people remember. A person discharged after a conviction for a statutory crime of violence remains prohibited from possessing firearms or ammunition “for the remainder of the person’s lifetime.” Read the next sentence. It says what happens if that same person receives federal relief under 18 U.S.C. § 925. The Legislature put both sentences in the same subdivision. Both deserve to be read. [1]

For decades, there was little practical reason to spend much time on that second sentence. Then, on November 4, the U.S. Department of Justice opened its firearm rights restoration process to the public. All 5,000 spots in the first round have been claimed. People who already started an application can finish it. DOJ has scheduled the next round for January 4, 2027, with 500 additional spots and a $30 application fee. [2] [3]

If you’re in Minnesota and wondering whether to wait for one of those spots, the first thing I’d want to see is the judgment of conviction. A Minnesota conviction and a federal conviction can both keep you from possessing a firearm. Which court entered that judgment makes a considerable difference in what a Minnesota judge can do about it. [1] [7]

How Congress Left a Remedy on the Books and Nobody to Decide It

Congress gave the Attorney General authority to relieve an individual of a federal firearm prohibition under § 925(c). ATF handled those applications. Beginning in 1992, Congress prohibited ATF from spending money to investigate or act on individual requests. Someone reading the United States Code would find a statute authorizing an application and another sentence providing judicial review if the application was denied. What happened if ATF mailed the paperwork back? [4] [5]

Thomas Bean found out. ATF returned his application and explained that Congress had prohibited it from acting. Bean went to federal court. The Supreme Court held that § 925(c) required an actual denial before a court could review the decision. ATF had made no decision at all. Congress had managed to leave the application, the remedy, and the right to judicial review in the statute while funding none of the work ATF needed to do for Bean to get an answer. United States v. Bean, 537 U.S. 71, 74–78 (2002). [5]

DOJ’s new rule puts that work in the Office of the Pardon Attorney. The name can cause some confusion. A grant under § 925(c) relieves a firearm disability. The conviction stays on the record. What has changed is that an applicant can now get a federal decision, and an actual denial can be reviewed in the U.S. district court where the applicant lives. [4] [8]

What DOJ Has to Decide About the Person Applying

Section 925(c) directs the Attorney General to consider what gave rise to the prohibition, the applicant’s record, and the applicant’s reputation. The question is whether the person is likely to act in a way that endangers public safety and whether granting relief would be contrary to the public interest. Someone who finished probation fifteen years ago has answered a question about when the sentence ended. What happened during those fifteen years bears on the question Congress actually asked. [4] [5]

DOJ’s rule also tells you why the judgment alone may be insufficient. In deciding whether a presumption against relief applies, the Attorney General can examine the conduct underlying a conviction. Some presumptions last five years, others ten, and some have no expiration date. An applicant facing one must show extraordinary circumstances to overcome it. The offense printed on the judgment is where the analysis starts. The plea transcript may explain why two applicants with the same offense on paper get different decisions. 28 C.F.R. §§ 107.10(b), 107.50 (2026). [4]

Minnesota Wrote the Federal Exception into the Penalty, Too

DOJ cautions that a federal grant can leave a state firearm prohibition in place. Fair enough. The Attorney General doesn’t get to rewrite Minnesota law. But that observation leaves an important question unanswered. What did Minnesota write? [1] [8]

Start with the discharged person covered by § 609.165, subdivision 1a. The second sentence recognizes federal relief under § 925 or restoration by a Minnesota court under subdivision 1d. Either removes the restriction imposed by that subdivision. Now read subdivision 1b(c). It expressly excepts a person who received federal relief from the criminal penalty for possession. Then look at § 624.713, subdivision 2(b), the provision carrying a potential fifteen-year sentence for possession by a person convicted of a crime of violence. The federal exception is there, too. Minn. Stat. §§ 609.165, subds. 1a, 1b(c), 624.713, subd. 2(b) (2026). [1] [6]

Suppose a discharged Minnesotan’s only prohibition comes from the qualifying conviction, and DOJ grants relief. If the State later charges that person under the crime-of-violence possession provision, the defense can point directly to the exception in the statute carrying the penalty. Change one fact. Suppose there’s also a current court order independently prohibiting possession. That order still needs its own analysis. The federal grant matters in both examples. Only in the first does it answer the whole question. [1] [6] [8]

Who Actually Needs to Wait for January?

Take two people who live in Minnesota and finished their sentences years ago. The first has a Minnesota conviction for a crime of violence. State law already allows that person to petition a Minnesota court for restoration after release from physical confinement. The court may grant the petition for good cause. A denial ordinarily means waiting three years to try again unless the court allows an earlier petition. Nothing about DOJ filling its first 5,000 spots closes the Minnesota courthouse. Minn. Stat. § 609.165, subd. 1d (2026). [1]

The second person has a federal felony conviction. Same address. Same years since discharge. Different court entered the judgment. The Supreme Court held that the law of the convicting jurisdiction controls whether civil rights have been restored for purposes of the federal felon-in-possession statute. A Minnesota restoration order cannot supply the federal restoration needed for a federal conviction. Beecham v. United States, 511 U.S. 368, 370–74 (1994). [7]

That second person is the one I’d have in mind when assessing what DOJ changed. For the first, there was already a judge with authority to hear the case. For the second, the statute promised an individual decision for more than thirty years while the agency assigned to make it kept sending the paperwork back. Getting someone to decide the application is a modest thing to call progress. Ask Thomas Bean how much turns on it. [4] [5] [7]

Related reading: Minnesota Gun Rights Restoration After a Conviction

Sources & Further Reading

  1. Minn. Stat. § 609.165, subds. 1a, 1b(c), 1d (2026).
  2. U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Firearm Rights Restoration rollout schedule.
  3. U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Firearm Rights Restoration application status.
  4. DOJ final rule, 91 Fed. Reg. 54,054, 54,088–93 (Aug. 20, 2026) (codified at 28 C.F.R. pt. 107).
  5. United States v. Bean, 537 U.S. 71, 74–78 (2002).
  6. Minn. Stat. § 624.713, subds. 1(2), 2(b) (2026).
  7. Beecham v. United States, 511 U.S. 368, 370–74 (1994).
  8. U.S. Department of Justice, Final Decision and Next Steps.

Questions About Firearm Rights Restoration?

Rob and his team can review the judgment and discharge order, identify which restrictions apply, and discuss what a restoration order could accomplish.

Schedule a Free Consultation